Case Details

General Information

Case Number
23CRB00781
Attorney Name
DOROTHY L WILLIAMS
Assigned To
STEPHANIE M BISHOP
Offense Date
6/17/2023
Date Filed
6/21/2023
Waiverable
No
Affiant Name
Affiant Type
City of Findlay PD
Proof of Insurance
Unknown
Muni Name
City of Findlay

Defendant Information

Name
ARTHUR THOMAS TOOTHILL
Address Line 1
1121 BROAD AVE
Address Line 2
City
FINDLAY
State
OH
ZIP Code
45840
DLN
T340058922610
DOB
7/21/1992

Financial Information

Total Cost
$3,894.00
Total Paid
$0.00
Total Owed
$3,894.00

Vehicle Information

Plate State
OH
Plate Number
Vehicle Year
Vehicle Make
Vehicle Model
Vehicle Color

Warrant Information

Active Warrants
No

Counts

Count Number Citation Number Statute Code Statute Description Plea Finding Finding Date Adjudicated By
1 2312692 537.03 ASSAULT - SIMPLE GUILTY GUILTY 4/2/2024 MATTHEW A CUNNINGHAM
Count Number
1
Citation Number
2312692
Statute Code
537.03
Statute Description
ASSAULT - SIMPLE
Plea
GUILTY
Finding
GUILTY
Finding Date
4/2/2024
Adjudicated By
MATTHEW A CUNNINGHAM

Hearing Information

Description Court Date/Time Court Room Heard By
Revocation 9/13/2024 9:00:00 AM 2 STEPHANIE M BISHOP
Plea 4/2/2024 1:30:00 PM 2 STEPHANIE M BISHOP
Pre-Trial with Judge 3/12/2024 1:30:00 PM 3 STEPHANIE M BISHOP
Pre-Trial with Judge 12/19/2023 10:45:00 AM 2 STEPHANIE M BISHOP
SECOND PRETRIAL 10/17/2023 9:30:00 AM 203 STEPHANIE M BISHOP
Pre-Trial 8/29/2023 10:30:00 AM 203 STEPHANIE M BISHOP
Pre-Trial with Judge 8/15/2023 1:30:00 PM 2 STEPHANIE M BISHOP
Arraignment 6/28/2023 8:30:00 AM

Docket Information

Entry Date Entry Text
7/1/2024 Written ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AS COUNSEL filed by Defendant's Attorney on 07/01/2024
6/21/2024 Defendant found indigent. Court appoints DOROTHY L WILLIAMS as counsel.
6/21/2024 Entry – Appointment of Counsel: This matter comes on for consideration of the Defendant’s request for the appointment of counsel. Upon consideration of said request, the Court finds: Defendant’s request well taken for the following reason(s): Public Defender has conflict of interest. It is therefore ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED that __Dorothy Williams__ Esq., an attorney at law admitted to practice before the bar of the State of Ohio, be appointed for the above named Defendant to be paid for at public expense, upon the following conditions: The $25.00 application fee shall be assessed as costs. s/by Judge Stephanie M. Bishop
6/18/2024 Warrant Block Release Sent to BMV
6/13/2024 Written LETTER RECEIVED FROM HCPD DOES QUALIFY FOR COURT APPOINTED BUT HAS A CONFLICT WITH HCPD filed by Third Party on 06/13/2024
6/13/2024 Judgment This Day, June 13, 2024 This matter came on for consideration. It is the order, judgment and decree of this court that IT HAS COME TO THE COURT'S ATTENTION THAT THE DEFENDANT WAS BOOKED INTO THE HANCOCK COUNTY JUSTICE CENTER ON 06/12/2024 FOR A HANCOCK COUNTY COMMON PLEAS COURT SECRET INDICTMENT. IN ADDITION, HE WAS ALSO BOOKED IN ON FINDLAY MUNICIPAL COURT PROBATION VIOLATIONS ON IN CASE NUMBERS 23CRB00738, 23CRB00781, AND 23TRD03341. THE DEFENDANT WAS RELEASED BY PROBATION OFFICER POWELL TO DEPUTY CROPCHO TO BE ESCORTED TO THE JAIL FOR PROCESSING. HOWEVER, IN ERROR, THE PAPERWORK THAT THE DEFENDANT WAS BOOKED IN ON WERE THE DEFENDANT COPIES OF THE PROBATION VIOLATIONS AS THE BENCH WARRANTS FOR THESE CASES HAD PREVIOUSLY BEEN RECALLED AND TAKEN OUT OF LEADS. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED THAT DEFENDANT SHALL BE RELEASED AS TO ALL CHARGES ON CASE NUMBERS 23CRB00738, 23CRB00781, AND 23TRD03341. STEPHANIE M BISHOP JUDGE
6/13/2024 BW RETURNED BY PROBATION OFFICER POWELL - NON COMP PROBATION (RECALLED)
6/13/2024 Warrant for NON COMPLIANCE - PROBATION Recalled On 06/12/2024
6/12/2024 Probation violation serve by Probation Officer Powell.
6/12/2024 Assignment Notice File Issued
6/12/2024 Revocation set for 09/13/2024 at 09:00 AM in room 2 by JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP Hearing was set on 06/12/2024 PROBATION VIOLATION - DEFENDANT IS NOT IN JAIL
6/10/2024 RECD NONCOMPLIANCE REPORT FROM GREAT LAKES RECOVERY DEF FAILED TO COMPLETE TREATMENT
6/6/2024 RECD UPDATE REPORT FROM GREAT LAKES RECOVERY DEF IS PURSUING RECOMMENDED TREATMENT
5/21/2024 RECD UPDATE REPORT FROM GREAT LAKES RECOVERY DEF IS PURSUING RECOMMENDED TREATMENT
5/15/2024 RECD UPDATE REPORT FROM SUREST PATH DEF IS PURSUING RECOMMENDED TREATMENT
4/16/2024 Warrant Block Sent to BMV
4/15/2024 BW (NON COMP PROBATION) ISSUED TO FPD FOR SERVICE
4/12/2024 Case sent to BCI&I on 04122024
4/12/2024 PROBATION WARRANT Issued
4/12/2024 BENCH WARRANT FEE of $25.00 assessed
4/12/2024 Warrant issued for NON COMPLIANCE - PROBATION on 04/12/2024
4/4/2024 DEFT APPEARED FOR FINGERPRINTING ON 04/03/2024 AT 11:14AM FILED BY FPD (CIEPLOWSKI)
4/3/2024 Finger Print Return Issued
4/3/2024 Finger Print Requirements Issued
4/2/2024 WARRANT TO DISCHARGE Issued
4/2/2024 MAGISTRATE SENTENCING ENTRY Issued
4/2/2024 The defendant appeared in open court and was advised of the nature of the charge, possible penalties, right to counsel, right to jury/court trial, other rights and the various pleas available.The defendant thereafter entered a plea of GUILTY to the charge. The Court heard evidence from the prosecution to substantiate the charge. The court entered a finding of GUILTY to the charge.Parties hereby consent to this matter being heard by the Magistrates. Parties Hereby waive any rights to object to the Magistrates decision. A Party shall not assign or appeal the Court's adoption of a factual finding or legal conclusion unless the party has filed objections pursuant to Rule 17 of the Ohio Rules of Criminal Procedure.It is ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that the defendant is found GUILTY of ASSAULT - SIMPLEORC/CO 537.03, and is sentenced as follows:1) A fine of $250.00 plus all costs 2) A jail sentence of 60 Day(s) with 30 Day(s) suspended consecutive to be scheduled by the Clerk's office. The defendant is ordered to pay all costs of confinement in a jail or other residential facility pursuant to ORC 2929.28, including but not limited to, a per diem fee for room and board in the jail of up to $108.00 per day, and any other costs provided by statute. 3) Defendant shall obtain an ALCOHOL/SUBSTANCE ABUSE evaluation from a state certified counselor within 30 days, and pursue any recommended course of treatment, and shall further be required to notify this Court every 30 days of his progress 4) Credit for 30 Day(s) days served. 5) No criminal conduct for 2 Year(s).6) Defendant shall be placed on probation for 1 Year(s).
4/2/2024 Plea of GUILTY entered on 04/02/2024
4/2/2024 Confinement Jail Time Sentenced 60 Day(s) 30 Credited 30 Suspended
4/2/2024 Finding of GUILTY entered for 537.03 - ASSAULT - SIMPLE
4/2/2024 Evaluation Referral Issued
3/12/2024 Commitment Pending Hearing Issued
3/12/2024 NOTICE FEE of $5.00 assessed
3/12/2024 Assignment Notice File Issued
3/12/2024 Plea set for 04/02/2024 at 01:30 PM in room 2 by JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP Hearing was set on 03/12/2024
3/12/2024 TC Judgment Entry Issued
3/12/2024 Warrant Block Release Sent to BMV
3/12/2024 Judgment This Day, March 12, 2024 This matter came on for consideration. It is the order, judgment and decree of this court that THIS MATTER CAME BEFORE THE COURT TODAY FOR A PRETRIAL WITH THE COURT. PRESENT IN COURT WAS ASSISTANCE CITY PROSECUTOR KALINA VAJSKOP REPRESENTING THE CITY OF FINDLAY. THE DEFENDANT WAS PRESENT BY VIDEO THROUGH THE HANCOCK COUNTY JUSTICE CENTER. HE WAS NOT REPRESENTED BY COUNSEL. THE COURT WENT OFF THE RECORD IN ORDER FOR THE PARTIES TO CONDUCT PRETRIAL DISCUSSIONS. AFTER DISCUSSIONS WERE CONCLUDED, THE COURT WENT BACK ON THE RECORD. THE COURT WAS INFORMED THAT THE PARTIES HAD AGREED THAT THIS MATTER SHALL BE SET FOR A PLEA HEARING. BOND SHALL CONTINUE AS ORDERED IN THE WARRANT. MATTHEW A CUNNINGHAM Magistrate
3/8/2024 Assignment Notice File Issued
3/8/2024 Pre-Trial with Judge set for 03/12/2024 at 01:30 PM in room 3 by JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP Hearing was set on 03/08/2024
3/8/2024 BW RETURNED BY FPD (STALEY) FOR FTA PTWJ WITH SERV $20.00 FEE
3/8/2024 BW (FTA PTWJ) SERVED BY FPD (STALEY)
3/8/2024 Warrant for FTA CR HEARING was Served on 03/07/2024
12/26/2023 Warrant Block Sent to BMV
12/20/2023 BW (FTA PTWJ) ISSUED TO (FPD) FOR SERVICE
12/19/2023 This matter came on for consideration this day 12/19/2023. The defendant having been duly served, failed to appear. It is therefore ORDERED that a Bench Warrant for the Defendant's arrest over a cash or surety bond in the amount of $1000.00.It is further ordered that the delay be charged against the Defendant pursuant to Revised Code 2945.72(D).
12/19/2023 JE Continuance Issued
12/19/2023 BENCH WARRANT FEE of $25.00 assessed
12/19/2023 CR FTA Hearing Bench Warrant Issued
12/19/2023 Warrant issued for FTA CR HEARING on 12/19/2023
11/28/2023 Attorney representation withdrawn
11/28/2023 MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL GRANTED by STEPHANIE M BISHOP JUDGE on 11/28/2023 (THIS MATTER COMES ON FOR CONSIDERATION OF DREW J. MIHALIK'S ORAL MOTION FOR LEAVE TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT, ARTHUR THOMAS TOOTHILL, IN ALL CASES IN WHICH HE IS COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR MR. TOOTHILL AT THE HEARING HELD ON NOVEMBER 14, 2023. UPON DUE CONSIDERATION SAID MOTION IS FOUND TO BE WELL TAKEN IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT DREW J. MIHALIK IS PERMITTED TO WITHDRAW AS DEFENDANT'S COUNSEL OF RECORD IMMEDIATELY.)
11/28/2023 Written MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL filed by Defendant's Attorney on 11/28/2023
10/25/2023 Assignment Notice File Issued
10/25/2023 Pre-Trial with Judge set for 12/19/2023 at 10:45 AM in room 2 by JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP Hearing was set on 10/25/2023
9/8/2023 Assignment Notice File Issued
9/8/2023 SECOND PRETRIAL set for 10/17/2023 at 09:30 AM in room 203 by JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP Hearing was set on 09/08/2023
8/17/2023 Assignment Notice File Issued
8/17/2023 Pre-Trial set for 08/29/2023 at 10:30 AM in room 203 by JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP Hearing was set on 08/17/2023
7/10/2023 Assignment Notice File Issued
7/10/2023 Pre-Trial with Judge set for 08/15/2023 at 01:30 PM in room 2 by JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP Hearing was set on 07/10/2023
7/10/2023 CANCELLED Pre-Trial for 07/18/2023 at 02:45 PM in room 203 by JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP
7/10/2023 Atty Mihalik requests that this matter be set for pretrial with court along with other cases.
6/28/2023 Assignment Notice File Issued
6/28/2023 Pre-Trial set for 07/18/2023 at 02:45 PM in room 203 by JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP
6/28/2023 Jury Demanded on 06/28/2023 by Attorney
6/28/2023 Right to speedy trial waived by defendant on 06/28/2023
6/28/2023 Plea of NOT GUILTY entered on 06/28/2023
6/28/2023 JUDGE STEPHANIE M BISHOP assigned to case
6/28/2023 REQUEST FOR PRETRIAL filed by Defendant's Attorney on 06/28/2023
6/28/2023 WAIVOR OF STATUTORY TIME LIMITATION filed by Defendant's Attorney on 06/28/2023
6/28/2023 WRITTEN PLEA OF NOT GUILTY filed by Defendant's Attorney on 06/28/2023
6/28/2023 DREW MIHALIK filed notice of appearance
6/28/2023 Written ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AS COUNSEL filed by Defendant's Attorney on 06/28/2023
6/21/2023 Arraignment set for 06/28/2023 at 08:30 AM
6/21/2023 Case Filed on 06/21/2023

© 2024 - City of Findlay